Ministry funding debacle
From The Detail, 5:00 am today
Tom Kitchin, co-host of The Detail
@inkitchnz tom.kitchin@rnz.co.nz
Disability funding changes have caused stress, uncertainty, and fear among families. How was this controversial decision made, and what happens now?
Listen (Duration 24':05")
A shock announcement about service cuts from the Ministry of Disabled People, delivered via social media, caused panic and grief. That was just the beginning of a chaotic few weeks, involving condemnations of the move from outside and inside the government and an apology from the ministry - but crucially, not a reversal of the changes.
Today's episode of The Detail explains how it unfolded.
"Whaikaha [Ministry of Disabled People] put a post on its social media pages and updated its website to say that the purchasing guidelines had been changed," says Newsroom journalist Emma Hatton.
"The purchasing guidelines are a list of criteria that people who receive certain disability supports can use to guide whether they are able to purchase something...what Whaikaha did is they changed that criteria and they made it more restrictive so they narrowed what people could purchase."
Dr Rebekah Graham, the national executive officer of Parents of Vision Impaired NZ, says the funding stream most parents receive is called Carer Support.
"Traditionally you could only use it to pay for a support worker," she says.
But that changed over time and became more flexible, to allow families to meet their individual needs.
"Instead of just being for a care worker, you could actually start using it for things that gave you, as the carer, a bit of a break."
This could include things like going overseas to attend a specialised programme, a tablet to keep a child engaged while a parent had a moment to sit down, or devices used to monitor a diabetic child's blood sugar overnight so that parents don't have to wake every few hours to make sure their child doesn't die in their sleep.
Graham says that, as she understands it, these changes will get rid of those options.
"It hasn't been this grim in such a long time. Because as parents we're so enmeshed in the system, it's so familiar to us, we recognise the language. As soon as we read the announcement, we knew that all of our supports were gone... some parents were really distressed."
Emma Hatton says the ministry told their minister, Penny Simmonds, about budget issues on February 22.
"They said that they were getting really close to spending more than what they had been allocated in the budget, and so in order to make it to the end of the financial year, they would need to stop spending. One of the ways they decided to stop spending is by restricting what disabled people and their carers could purchase."
What happened between then and the announcement remains a bit of a mystery, Hatton says.
However, Finance Minister Nicola Willis has said she was caught by surprise with the announcement. The budget will be topped up to get through the end of the year, but "that doesn't change what has been adjusted with the purchasing guidelines, so that doesn't actually help real people on the ground," Hatton says.
"Willis has confirmed that Cabinet has decided that any further decisions now that this ministry makes about changing its criteria or its funds or anything that like needs to be properly consulted, properly sequenced.
"So basically, if this ministry wants to do anything from now on, it's going to have to get its minister Penny Simmonds to take a paper to Cabinet and then Cabinet will have to sign off on it."
"That's quite a level of oversight, quite a step up."
Willis has promised the ministry will get "vast orders of magnitude more" in frontline service funding - but how much remains unclear.
Disabled People in NZ unite to defend our right to control our lives and the support we need through Enabling Good Lives (EGL).
Blog Archive
-
▼
2024
(229)
- ► October 2024 (1)
- ► September 2024 (19)
- ► August 2024 (14)
-
▼
April 2024
(67)
- Day 41 - DCC - Dunedin City Council calls on gover...
- Day 41 - Community Law - Empowering Disability Rig...
- Day 41 - TVNZ - Govt launches independent review i...
- Day 41 - Stuff - Government announces there will b...
- Day 41 - NZ Herald - Disability ministry’s problem...
- Day 40 - RNZ - Public service cuts: Ministry accus...
- Day 40 - DUNZ - Unite all disabled people
- Day 39 - Newshub - Single mum of disabled daughter...
- Day 38 - DUNZ - National Meeting of DUNZ on Zoom
- Day 38 - Northern Advocate - Disability funding cu...
- Day 37 - Manawanui - Community Network Meetings
- Day 37 - The D*List - The hidden detail in this we...
- Day 36 - Southland Deaf Community Leader Speaks Out
- Day 34 - Disabled ministry gives new 'clarificatio...
- Day 33 - The D*List - Tāmaki Makaurau disability c...
- Day 33 - The Spinoff - There’s no need to make eme...
- Day 33 - Auckland - Speech by Paul Brown at Auckla...
- Day 32 - Protest Rally in Auckland City
- Day 31 - NATINA - Letter of Concern to Minister of...
- Day 31 - ODT - Disability advocates protest policy...
- Day 30 - Disabled United - Invercargill Organising...
- Day 30 - Dunedin Disability Funding Cuts Protest
- Day 29 - NewsHub - Care workers the invisible mode...
- Day 28 - The NZ Herald - Family Carers disappointe...
- Day 28 - Tracy Peters - Letters to Whaikaha
- Day 28 - Blenheim Sun - ‘Financial constraint and ...
- Day 26 - NewsHub - Carers want out from disability...
- Day 27 - SunLive - Health Initiative Targeting Vul...
- Day 26 - Lisa Wheeler - A Poem to Whaikaha Ministr...
- Day 26 - RNZ - Family carers 'not employed' by gov...
- Day 26 - RNZ - Accessibility impacting disabled s...
- Day 26 - Disabled United - A Plan
- Day 26 - Nelson Mail - 'At breaking point': disabi...
- Background - Newsroom - I wish my role were redundant
- Day 24 - Disabled United - National Media Team
- Day 26 - Disabled United - Changes to the website
- Day 25 - Carers NZ - Letter to Simmonds
- Background - Newsroom - Disability funding not bes...
- Day 25 - RNZ - Continued funding concerns among di...
- Day 24 - Arts Access Aotearoa - We are people, not...
- Day 24 -Awhi Ngā Mātua - Share your examples
- Background - NZ On Air - 'We want to work': Nation...
- Day 23 - Disabled United - Palmerston North - Sign...
- Day 23 - Palmerston North - Take Back Control
- Day 23 - Protest rally on 21 April in Auckland City
- Day 22 - Disabled United - Logo options
- Day 22 - Disabled United - Invercargill Organising...
- Day 21 - DUNZ - Monday 8 April 2024 - News about t...
- Day 22 - SunLive - Disability Sports Festival in A...
- Day 21 - Disabled United - Disregarded and Disresp...
- DIY - How to be a public speaker
- Day 20 - Disabled United - Photos from the Inverca...
- DIY - How to be interviewed by the media
- Media - Scoop
- Day 19 - DPA - Disability funding changes - initia...
- Day 19 - NZLP - Public meeting about disability su...
- Day 19 - OPINION - Report on local community event
- Media - Manawatu Standard
- Day 19 - Manawatu Standard - Frustration and fears...
- DIY - How to organise in 11 easy steps
- Day 17 - Palmerston North Community Led Forum
- Day 17 - Dunedin Disability Funding Cuts Protest ...
- Day 15 - Invercargill protest on Thursday May 2
- Day 15 - IComPA - Statement by The Institute of C...
- Day 15 - RNZ - The Detail - Ministry Funding Debacle
- Day 14 - Leaders of protests meetup
- Media - NZ Herald
- ► March 2024 (51)
- ► February 2024 (1)